TB
TrophyBook
Ohio harvest intel
Buckeye Big Buck Club · ODNR record book

Ohio non-typical whitetail records

Every non-typical buck in the Buckeye Big Buck Club record book, ranked by net score. Non-typical racks only (minimum 160 inches).

Source: Buckeye Big Buck Club record book (ODNR), retrieved Sep 15, 2026. How the records work

WeaponAllModern ShotgunCrossbowLong BowMuzzleloaderStraight-Walled RifleHand Gun
DecadeAll2020s2010s2000s1990s1980sBefore 1980
Adams: 55 entriesAllen: 16 entriesAshland: 80 entriesAshtabula: 40 entriesAthens: 73 entriesAuglaize: 30 entriesBelmont: 48 entriesBrown: 39 entriesButler: 27 entriesCarroll: 66 entriesChampaign: 33 entriesClark: 18 entriesClermont: 40 entriesClinton: 46 entriesColumbiana: 45 entriesCoshocton: 104 entriesCrawford: 40 entriesCuyahoga: 13 entriesDarke: 23 entriesDefiance: 21 entriesDelaware: 87 entriesErie: 21 entriesFairfield: 91 entriesFayette: 21 entriesFranklin: 60 entriesFulton: 13 entriesGallia: 40 entriesGeauga: 20 entriesGreene: 28 entriesGuernsey: 63 entriesHamilton: 26 entriesHancock: 46 entriesHardin: 44 entriesHarrison: 58 entriesHenry: 16 entriesHighland: 68 entriesHocking: 44 entriesHolmes: 40 entriesHuron: 45 entriesJackson: 48 entriesJefferson: 68 entriesKnox: 93 entriesLake: 9 entriesLawrence: 14 entriesLicking: 164 entriesLogan: 49 entriesLorain: 60 entriesLucas: 23 entriesMadison: 23 entriesMahoning: 35 entriesMarion: 33 entriesMedina: 38 entriesMeigs: 49 entriesMercer: 10 entriesMiami: 20 entriesMonroe: 20 entriesMontgomery: 17 entriesMorgan: 52 entriesMorrow: 78 entriesMuskingum: 97 entriesNoble: 46 entriesOttawa: 8 entriesPaulding: 18 entriesPerry: 57 entriesPickaway: 39 entriesPike: 41 entriesPortage: 38 entriesPreble: 25 entriesPutnam: 7 entriesRichland: 57 entriesRoss: 114 entriesSandusky: 41 entriesScioto: 38 entriesSeneca: 37 entriesShelby: 23 entriesStark: 38 entriesSummit: 29 entriesTrumbull: 29 entriesTuscarawas: 90 entriesUnion: 32 entriesVan Wert: 7 entriesVinton: 44 entriesWarren: 40 entriesWashington: 56 entriesWayne: 39 entriesWilliams: 32 entriesWood: 28 entriesWyandot: 51 entries

Where they were taken

Licking County: 164 entries.

Show every countyLicking County page

  1. Licking164
  2. Ross114
  3. Coshocton104
  4. Muskingum97
  5. Knox93
  6. Fairfield91
  7. Tuscarawas90
  8. Delaware87

Ranked by net score

164 of 3,818 entries match · page 1 of 4

  1. #1Non-typical
    241 1/8Jim FairchildLicking · 1994 · Modern Shotgun
  2. #2Non-typical
    232 1/8Scott WalshLicking · 2001 · Crossbow
  3. #3Non-typical
    231 4/8Norman L MyersLicking · 1964 · Modern Shotgun
  4. #4Non-typical
    226 6/8David BareLicking · 1989 · Modern Shotgun
  5. #5Non-typical
    226 5/8John S BlytheLicking · 1999 · Crossbow
  6. #6Non-typical
    219 6/8Jeff KaiserLicking · 2010 · Long Bow
  7. #7Non-typical
    212 5/8Chris LepleyLicking · 2001 · Long Bow
  8. #8Non-typical
    211 5/8Ted SloneLicking · 2009 · Crossbow
  9. #9Non-typical
    211 2/8Grant GarberLicking · 2015 · Crossbow
  10. #10Non-typical
    210 3/8Carl EfflerLicking · 2013 · Crossbow
#HunterScoreYearCountyWeapon
#11John J Carlisle
Millerport
207 1/82002LickingCrossbow
#12Joseph F Wayne
Johnstown
203 6/82007LickingModern Shotgun
#13Ty Yoho
Granville
202 5/82002LickingCrossbow
#14Don Spires
St. Louisville
202 4/81998LickingLong Bow
#15David A Nichols
Johnstown
202 1/82007LickingLong Bow
#16Adam Wells
Columbus
201 6/82016LickingLong Bow
#17Jeff Reichert
St Louisville
200 0/81991LickingCrossbow
#18Terry Garee
Heath
199 1/82002LickingModern Shotgun
#19Henry R Jackson
Columbus
198 7/82003LickingModern Shotgun
#20Robert Wingeier
Granville
198 6/82008LickingLong Bow
#21Steve Esker
Reynoldsburg
198 1/81994LickingCrossbow
#22Benjamin Funk
Johnstown
197 3/82021LickingCrossbow
#23Carl Morris, Jr
Johnstown
197 3/82011LickingCrossbow
#24Devin Danflous
Johnstown
197 1/82011LickingModern Shotgun
#25Michael E Evans
Granville
196 6/81994LickingCrossbow
#26Jake Lindsey
Granville
196 1/82007LickingModern Shotgun
#27Mike Miller
Mt. Vernon
196 0/82013LickingLong Bow
#28Steve Bradley
Newark
195 7/82006LickingModern Shotgun
#29George Smith
Newark
195 0/81995LickingCrossbow
#30Roger J Holbrook
Blacklick
192 1/82000LickingCrossbow
#31Mike Smith
Utica
192 0/81990LickingHand Gun
#32Derrick Holter
Johnstown
190 5/82017LickingCrossbow
#33John McGee
Hillsdale
190 4/81982LickingLong Bow
#34Dave Pope
Columbus
190 1/82002LickingModern Shotgun
#35Gary D Smith
Hebron
190 0/82021LickingCrossbow
#36Steve Esker
Etna
190 0/82014LickingCrossbow
#37Gary Kirsch
Freemont
189 6/82006LickingModern Shotgun
#38David Bravard
Bristol
189 0/81993LickingModern Shotgun
#39Eric Ashcraft
Utica
188 0/82000LickingLong Bow
#40Dan Peck
Galloway
187 7/81994LickingModern Shotgun
#41Merle Beachy
Dundee
187 7/82018LickingLong Bow
#42Daniel Shipman
Alexandria
187 3/82009LickingLong Bow
#43Brad Shepler
Nashport
187 0/81994LickingModern Shotgun
#44Gavin Mawhorr
Zanesville
186 3/82020LickingMuzzleloader
#45James P Hall
Beloit
186 3/82003LickingModern Shotgun
#46Melvin L Hoskinson
Heath
186 1/81978LickingModern Shotgun
#47Chris Beale
Alexandria
186 0/82005LickingMuzzleloader
#48Terry L Paxton
Junction City
185 5/81989LickingLong Bow
#49Danielle T Thomas
Glenford
185 1/82021LickingCrossbow
#50Steve Owens
Pataskala
185 1/82001LickingCrossbow

Page views are counted with Vercel Analytics. No ads, and we don't sell your data. Privacy · Terms

Ohio non-typical whitetail records — TrophyBook