TB
TrophyBook
Ohio harvest intel
Buckeye Big Buck Club · ODNR record book

Ohio non-typical whitetail records

Every non-typical buck in the Buckeye Big Buck Club record book, ranked by net score. Non-typical racks only (minimum 160 inches).

Source: Buckeye Big Buck Club record book (ODNR), retrieved Sep 15, 2026. How the records work

WeaponAllModern ShotgunCrossbowLong BowMuzzleloaderStraight-Walled RifleHand Gun
DecadeAll2020s2010s2000s1990s1980sBefore 1980
Adams: 55 entriesAllen: 16 entriesAshland: 80 entriesAshtabula: 40 entriesAthens: 73 entriesAuglaize: 30 entriesBelmont: 48 entriesBrown: 39 entriesButler: 27 entriesCarroll: 66 entriesChampaign: 33 entriesClark: 18 entriesClermont: 40 entriesClinton: 46 entriesColumbiana: 45 entriesCoshocton: 104 entriesCrawford: 40 entriesCuyahoga: 13 entriesDarke: 23 entriesDefiance: 21 entriesDelaware: 87 entriesErie: 21 entriesFairfield: 91 entriesFayette: 21 entriesFranklin: 60 entriesFulton: 13 entriesGallia: 40 entriesGeauga: 20 entriesGreene: 28 entriesGuernsey: 63 entriesHamilton: 26 entriesHancock: 46 entriesHardin: 44 entriesHarrison: 58 entriesHenry: 16 entriesHighland: 68 entriesHocking: 44 entriesHolmes: 40 entriesHuron: 45 entriesJackson: 48 entriesJefferson: 68 entriesKnox: 93 entriesLake: 9 entriesLawrence: 14 entriesLicking: 164 entriesLogan: 49 entriesLorain: 60 entriesLucas: 23 entriesMadison: 23 entriesMahoning: 35 entriesMarion: 33 entriesMedina: 38 entriesMeigs: 49 entriesMercer: 10 entriesMiami: 20 entriesMonroe: 20 entriesMontgomery: 17 entriesMorgan: 52 entriesMorrow: 78 entriesMuskingum: 97 entriesNoble: 46 entriesOttawa: 8 entriesPaulding: 18 entriesPerry: 57 entriesPickaway: 39 entriesPike: 41 entriesPortage: 38 entriesPreble: 25 entriesPutnam: 7 entriesRichland: 57 entriesRoss: 114 entriesSandusky: 41 entriesScioto: 38 entriesSeneca: 37 entriesShelby: 23 entriesStark: 38 entriesSummit: 29 entriesTrumbull: 29 entriesTuscarawas: 90 entriesUnion: 32 entriesVan Wert: 7 entriesVinton: 44 entriesWarren: 40 entriesWashington: 56 entriesWayne: 39 entriesWilliams: 32 entriesWood: 28 entriesWyandot: 51 entries

Where they were taken

Fayette County: 21 entries.

Show every countyFayette County page

  1. Licking164
  2. Ross114
  3. Coshocton104
  4. Muskingum97
  5. Knox93
  6. Fairfield91
  7. Tuscarawas90
  8. Delaware87

Ranked by net score

21 of 3,818 entries match

  1. #1Non-typical
    224 3/8James MillerFayette · 2015 · Long Bow
  2. #2Non-typical
    210 5/8Davey StuckeyFayette · 2022 · Crossbow
  3. #3Non-typical
    201 4/8Sherwin PayneFayette · 1992 · Muzzleloader
  4. #4Non-typical
    200 4/8Mark SharpFayette · 2013 · Long Bow
  5. #5Non-typical
    195 6/8Sean HuffFayette · 1999 · Modern Shotgun
  6. #6Non-typical
    192 6/8Scott A BoyerFayette · 2000 · Long Bow
  7. #7Non-typical
    188 0/8Jeff LitteralFayette · 2016 · Long Bow
  8. #8Non-typical
    186 2/8Steven J GuessFayette · 1984 · Long Bow
  9. #9Non-typical
    186 0/8Michael SmithFayette · 2011 · Crossbow
  10. #10Non-typical
    185 3/8Andrew BeattyFayette · 2013 · Crossbow
#HunterScoreYearCountyWeapon
#11Matthew Buchholtz
Grove City
185 1/82017FayetteMuzzleloader
#12Kaden Bryant
Washington CH
182 0/82021FayetteCrossbow
#13Barry O Thompson
Jeffersonville
174 7/81995FayetteModern Shotgun
#14Rick McCoy
Londonderry
174 2/81986FayetteModern Shotgun
#15Kyle Shupert
Washington C H
173 3/82004FayetteModern Shotgun
#16T J Cox
Greenfield
172 2/82005FayetteModern Shotgun
#17Justin Depugh
Chillicothe
165 1/81999FayetteCrossbow
#18Gerald L Downs
Washington C.H.
164 4/81983FayetteModern Shotgun
#19Kiara Rainsberger
Greenfield
164 4/82016FayetteStraight-Walled Rifle
#20Randy Hughes
Washington Courthouse
163 3/82020FayetteCrossbow
#21Ryan Creed
Washington CH
161 3/82006FayetteModern Shotgun

Page views are counted with Vercel Analytics. No ads, and we don't sell your data. Privacy · Terms

Ohio non-typical whitetail records — TrophyBook