TB
TrophyBook
Ohio harvest intel
Buckeye Big Buck Club · ODNR record book

Ohio non-typical whitetail records

Every non-typical buck in the Buckeye Big Buck Club record book, ranked by net score. Non-typical racks only (minimum 160 inches).

Source: Buckeye Big Buck Club record book (ODNR), retrieved Sep 15, 2026. How the records work

WeaponAllModern ShotgunCrossbowLong BowMuzzleloaderStraight-Walled RifleHand Gun
DecadeAll2020s2010s2000s1990s1980sBefore 1980
Adams: 55 entriesAllen: 16 entriesAshland: 80 entriesAshtabula: 40 entriesAthens: 73 entriesAuglaize: 30 entriesBelmont: 48 entriesBrown: 39 entriesButler: 27 entriesCarroll: 66 entriesChampaign: 33 entriesClark: 18 entriesClermont: 40 entriesClinton: 46 entriesColumbiana: 45 entriesCoshocton: 104 entriesCrawford: 40 entriesCuyahoga: 13 entriesDarke: 23 entriesDefiance: 21 entriesDelaware: 87 entriesErie: 21 entriesFairfield: 91 entriesFayette: 21 entriesFranklin: 60 entriesFulton: 13 entriesGallia: 40 entriesGeauga: 20 entriesGreene: 28 entriesGuernsey: 63 entriesHamilton: 26 entriesHancock: 46 entriesHardin: 44 entriesHarrison: 58 entriesHenry: 16 entriesHighland: 68 entriesHocking: 44 entriesHolmes: 40 entriesHuron: 45 entriesJackson: 48 entriesJefferson: 68 entriesKnox: 93 entriesLake: 9 entriesLawrence: 14 entriesLicking: 164 entriesLogan: 49 entriesLorain: 60 entriesLucas: 23 entriesMadison: 23 entriesMahoning: 35 entriesMarion: 33 entriesMedina: 38 entriesMeigs: 49 entriesMercer: 10 entriesMiami: 20 entriesMonroe: 20 entriesMontgomery: 17 entriesMorgan: 52 entriesMorrow: 78 entriesMuskingum: 97 entriesNoble: 46 entriesOttawa: 8 entriesPaulding: 18 entriesPerry: 57 entriesPickaway: 39 entriesPike: 41 entriesPortage: 38 entriesPreble: 25 entriesPutnam: 7 entriesRichland: 57 entriesRoss: 114 entriesSandusky: 41 entriesScioto: 38 entriesSeneca: 37 entriesShelby: 23 entriesStark: 38 entriesSummit: 29 entriesTrumbull: 29 entriesTuscarawas: 90 entriesUnion: 32 entriesVan Wert: 7 entriesVinton: 44 entriesWarren: 40 entriesWashington: 56 entriesWayne: 39 entriesWilliams: 32 entriesWood: 28 entriesWyandot: 51 entries

Where they were taken

Erie County: 21 entries.

Show every countyErie County page

  1. Licking164
  2. Ross114
  3. Coshocton104
  4. Muskingum97
  5. Knox93
  6. Fairfield91
  7. Tuscarawas90
  8. Delaware87

Ranked by net score

21 of 3,818 entries match

  1. #1Non-typical
    214 0/8Scott EisenhauerErie · 2017 · Crossbow
  2. #2Non-typical
    210 0/8Arnold G HamiltonErie · 2003 · Crossbow
  3. #3Non-typical
    203 4/8Joe BaxterErie · 2010 · Long Bow
  4. #4Non-typical
    203 1/8David J MayerErie · 1989 · Modern Shotgun
  5. #5Non-typical
    198 3/8Aaron FraleyErie · 2011 · Modern Shotgun
  6. #6Non-typical
    189 4/8Robert FaustErie · 2000 · Modern Shotgun
  7. #7Non-typical
    180 6/8David BohnErie · 2007 · Modern Shotgun
  8. #8Non-typical
    178 7/8Barry FialaErie · 2003 · Muzzleloader
  9. #9Non-typical
    178 0/8Alan JankowskiErie · 2017 · Crossbow
  10. #10Non-typical
    177 3/8Chester A AlexanderErie · 1989 · Long Bow
#HunterScoreYearCountyWeapon
#11Daniel McGlothlin
Vermillion
175 5/82011ErieLong Bow
#12Joseph Beleski
Westlake
171 6/81990ErieModern Shotgun
#13Robert Utter III
Huron
171 5/82016ErieLong Bow
#14Tyler Berthond
Huron
170 7/82022ErieLong Bow
#15John A Bizorik
Huron
170 3/81984ErieModern Shotgun
#16Rodger Norcross
Fredericktown
170 0/81998ErieCrossbow
#17John Leonard
Huron
167 0/82024ErieCrossbow
#18Russell Yates
Berlin Heights
166 3/81999ErieCrossbow
#19Brad McMahon
Castalia
164 6/81994ErieModern Shotgun
#20John Leonhard
Huron
164 3/82024ErieCrossbow
#21Brad Tully
Wakeman
163 5/82001ErieCrossbow

Page views are counted with Vercel Analytics. No ads, and we don't sell your data. Privacy · Terms

Ohio non-typical whitetail records — TrophyBook