TB
TrophyBook
Ohio harvest intel
Buckeye Big Buck Club · ODNR record book

Ohio non-typical whitetail records

Every non-typical buck in the Buckeye Big Buck Club record book, ranked by net score. Non-typical racks only (minimum 160 inches).

Source: Buckeye Big Buck Club record book (ODNR), retrieved Sep 15, 2026. How the records work

WeaponAllModern ShotgunCrossbowLong BowMuzzleloaderStraight-Walled RifleHand Gun
DecadeAll2020s2010s2000s1990s1980sBefore 1980
Adams: 55 entriesAllen: 16 entriesAshland: 80 entriesAshtabula: 40 entriesAthens: 73 entriesAuglaize: 30 entriesBelmont: 48 entriesBrown: 39 entriesButler: 27 entriesCarroll: 66 entriesChampaign: 33 entriesClark: 18 entriesClermont: 40 entriesClinton: 46 entriesColumbiana: 45 entriesCoshocton: 104 entriesCrawford: 40 entriesCuyahoga: 13 entriesDarke: 23 entriesDefiance: 21 entriesDelaware: 87 entriesErie: 21 entriesFairfield: 91 entriesFayette: 21 entriesFranklin: 60 entriesFulton: 13 entriesGallia: 40 entriesGeauga: 20 entriesGreene: 28 entriesGuernsey: 63 entriesHamilton: 26 entriesHancock: 46 entriesHardin: 44 entriesHarrison: 58 entriesHenry: 16 entriesHighland: 68 entriesHocking: 44 entriesHolmes: 40 entriesHuron: 45 entriesJackson: 48 entriesJefferson: 68 entriesKnox: 93 entriesLake: 9 entriesLawrence: 14 entriesLicking: 164 entriesLogan: 49 entriesLorain: 60 entriesLucas: 23 entriesMadison: 23 entriesMahoning: 35 entriesMarion: 33 entriesMedina: 38 entriesMeigs: 49 entriesMercer: 10 entriesMiami: 20 entriesMonroe: 20 entriesMontgomery: 17 entriesMorgan: 52 entriesMorrow: 78 entriesMuskingum: 97 entriesNoble: 46 entriesOttawa: 8 entriesPaulding: 18 entriesPerry: 57 entriesPickaway: 39 entriesPike: 41 entriesPortage: 38 entriesPreble: 25 entriesPutnam: 7 entriesRichland: 57 entriesRoss: 114 entriesSandusky: 41 entriesScioto: 38 entriesSeneca: 37 entriesShelby: 23 entriesStark: 38 entriesSummit: 29 entriesTrumbull: 29 entriesTuscarawas: 90 entriesUnion: 32 entriesVan Wert: 7 entriesVinton: 44 entriesWarren: 40 entriesWashington: 56 entriesWayne: 39 entriesWilliams: 32 entriesWood: 28 entriesWyandot: 51 entries

Where they were taken

Holmes County: 40 entries.

Show every countyHolmes County page

  1. Licking164
  2. Ross114
  3. Coshocton104
  4. Muskingum97
  5. Knox93
  6. Fairfield91
  7. Tuscarawas90
  8. Delaware87

Ranked by net score

40 of 3,818 entries match

  1. #1Non-typical
    244 0/8Jeffrey T KaserHolmes · 2003 · Long Bow
  2. #2Non-typical
    225 1/8Chris G HiderHolmes · 1998 · Modern Shotgun
  3. #3Non-typical
    198 2/8Eric TishHolmes · 2012 · Crossbow
  4. #4Non-typical
    197 4/8Brian YoderHolmes · 2019 · Long Bow
  5. #5Non-typical
    195 5/8Mike T AllerdingHolmes · 2000 · Modern Shotgun
  6. #6Non-typical
    195 1/8Randy StrohmingerHolmes · 1987 · Modern Shotgun
  7. #7Non-typical
    191 7/8Moses H MillerHolmes · 2001 · Muzzleloader
  8. #8Non-typical
    191 3/8Terry DalessandroHolmes · 2022 · Crossbow
  9. #9Non-typical
    189 2/8Larry ElliottHolmes · 2017 · Crossbow
  10. #10Non-typical
    187 4/8Steve TishHolmes · 2021 · Crossbow
#HunterScoreYearCountyWeapon
#11Ronald E Saum
Cortland
187 1/81956HolmesModern Shotgun
#12Arlen Erb
Millersburg
185 4/82006HolmesModern Shotgun
#13Larry E Smith
Fredericksburg
184 2/82001HolmesCrossbow
#14Daniel E Gingerich
Millersburg
183 2/82005HolmesLong Bow
#15Kevin Watts
Killbuck
182 5/82007HolmesMuzzleloader
#16Christopher Byler
Millersburg
180 4/82008HolmesLong Bow
#17Sharon Nussbaum
Crestline
179 1/81991HolmesModern Shotgun
#18Derrick Columbo
Loudonville
177 6/82015HolmesLong Bow
#19Richard Hendrickson
Orrville
177 0/81982HolmesModern Shotgun
#20Kevin Pamer
Creston
176 5/82002HolmesLong Bow
#21Norman Troyer
Millersburg
176 4/82017HolmesModern Shotgun
#22James L Evans
Shreve
176 1/82001HolmesModern Shotgun
#23Bill B Smith
Ashland
176 0/81977HolmesModern Shotgun
#24Jeffrey Stitzlein
Ashland
175 4/82023HolmesLong Bow
#25Chad Dail
Big Prarrie
174 3/82017HolmesLong Bow
#26Brock Burgett
Lakeville
174 2/82016HolmesLong Bow
#27Paul Sampsel
Wooster
173 2/82019HolmesModern Shotgun
#28Jesse Combs
Lakeville
170 6/82004HolmesCrossbow
#29David Miller
Lakeville
167 3/81989HolmesModern Shotgun
#30Matt Buzzard
Ashland
166 1/82002HolmesCrossbow
#31Jason Troyer
Millersburg
164 5/82015HolmesModern Shotgun
#32David Miller
Lakeville
164 3/81988HolmesModern Shotgun
#33Frank Lucci
Smithville
163 7/82017HolmesCrossbow
#34Hobert Davis
Barberton
163 5/81999HolmesModern Shotgun
#35Marvin L Hochstetler
Millersburg
163 1/81974HolmesModern Shotgun
#36Chuck Bender
Loudonville
162 7/82015HolmesModern Shotgun
#37Mike Bender
Loudonville
162 1/82004HolmesModern Shotgun
#38Mitch Tyson
Millersburg
161 4/82015HolmesLong Bow
#39Chuck Donley
Holmesville
161 3/81999HolmesModern Shotgun
#40Jim Kaser
Millersburg
160 0/82009HolmesModern Shotgun

Page views are counted with Vercel Analytics. No ads, and we don't sell your data. Privacy · Terms

Ohio non-typical whitetail records — TrophyBook