Buckeye Big Buck Club · ODNR record book
Ohio big buck records
Every officially scored buck in Ohio’s record book, ranked by net score. Typical bucks start at 140 inches, non-typical at 160.
Source: Buckeye Big Buck Club record book (ODNR), retrieved Sep 15, 2026. How the records work
Where they were taken
Fayette County: 104 entries.
Ranked by net score
104 of 21,879 entries match · page 1 of 3
- #1Non-typical224 3/8James Miller
- #2Non-typical210 5/8Davey Stuckey
- #3Non-typical201 4/8Sherwin Payne
- #4Non-typical200 4/8Mark Sharp
- #5Non-typical195 6/8Sean Huff
- #6Non-typical192 6/8Scott A Boyer
- #7Non-typical188 0/8Jeff Litteral
- #8Non-typical186 2/8Steven J Guess
- #9Non-typical186 0/8Michael Smith
- #10Non-typical185 3/8Andrew Beatty
| # | Hunter | Score | Year | County |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #11 | Matthew Buchholtz Grove City | 185 1/8 | 2017 | Fayette |
| #12 | Kaden Bryant Washington CH | 182 0/8 | 2021 | Fayette |
| #13 | Barry O Thompson Jeffersonville | 174 7/8 | 1995 | Fayette |
| #14 | Rick McCoy Londonderry | 174 2/8 | 1986 | Fayette |
| #15 | Ralph Hilderbrand Washington C. H. | 173 6/8 | 1986 | Fayette |
| #16 | Clinton Worley Leesburg | 173 3/8 | 1997 | Fayette |
| #17 | Kyle Shupert Washington C H | 173 3/8 | 2004 | Fayette |
| #18 | T J Cox Greenfield | 172 2/8 | 2005 | Fayette |
| #19 | Jerry Wilt Bloomingburg | 170 1/8 | 2004 | Fayette |
| #20 | Andy Beatty Greenfield | 169 2/8 | 2003 | Fayette |
| #21 | Fred L Jackson Greenfield | 166 3/8 | 1980 | Fayette |
| #22 | Harley Price Washington C. H. | 165 1/8 | 1994 | Fayette |
| #23 | Justin Depugh Chillicothe | 165 1/8 | 1999 | Fayette |
| #24 | Gerald L Downs Washington C.H. | 164 4/8 | 1983 | Fayette |
| #25 | Kiara Rainsberger Greenfield | 164 4/8 | 2016 | Fayette |
| #26 | Meghan Cory Washington CH | 164 0/8 | 2021 | Fayette |
| #27 | J R Johnson Washington Courtho | 163 5/8 | 2008 | Fayette |
| #28 | Randy Hughes Washington Courthouse | 163 3/8 | 2020 | Fayette |
| #29 | Patrick Ramey, Jr Mt Sterling | 162 5/8 | 2015 | Fayette |
| #30 | Michael Ball Washington C.H. | 162 4/8 | 1990 | Fayette |
| #31 | Davey Stucky Washington | 161 7/8 | 2023 | Fayette |
| #32 | Ryan Creed Washington CH | 161 3/8 | 2006 | Fayette |
| #33 | Nick Martin Wilmington | 161 0/8 | 2019 | Fayette |
| #34 | Matt Buell Earlville | 160 3/8 | 1998 | Fayette |
| #35 | Doug Hyer Washington CH | 159 2/8 | 2003 | Fayette |
| #36 | Brian Wallner Mt Sterling | 158 7/8 | 2006 | Fayette |
| #37 | Neal Hughes Jefferson | 158 1/8 | 1986 | Fayette |
| #38 | Bill Knapp Greenfield | 158 0/8 | 1988 | Fayette |
| #39 | Gary Bendele Cecil | 156 7/8 | 2018 | Fayette |
| #40 | Robert A Beedy Washington C.H. | 156 5/8 | 1987 | Fayette |
| #41 | Tracy Anders Washington C.H. | 156 1/8 | 1998 | Fayette |
| #42 | T L McFadden New Holland | 155 5/8 | 1986 | Fayette |
| #43 | Randy Hughes Washington | 155 3/8 | 2014 | Fayette |
| #44 | Harley Price Washington C.H. | 154 3/8 | 1992 | Fayette |
| #45 | Dallas Marshall Washington C.H. | 154 0/8 | 1982 | Fayette |
| #46 | Kevin Wheeler Washington CH | 153 4/8 | 2005 | Fayette |
| #47 | Jack L Flax Washington C.H. | 152 7/8 | 1996 | Fayette |
| #48 | Seth Simonson | 152 4/8 | 2012 | Fayette |
| #49 | Whitlow Wyatt Washington C.H. | 152 4/8 | 1996 | Fayette |
| #50 | Mara Simonson | 152 3/8 | 2014 | Fayette |