Buckeye Big Buck Club · ODNR record book

Ohio big buck records

Every officially scored buck in Ohio’s record book, ranked by net score. Typical bucks start at 140 inches, non-typical at 160.

Source: Buckeye Big Buck Club record book (ODNR), retrieved Sep 15, 2026. How the records work

WeaponAll Modern Shotgun Long Bow Crossbow Muzzleloader Straight-Walled Rifle Hand Gun

DecadeAll 2020s 2010s 2000s 1990s 1980s Before 1980

Where they were taken

Fairfield County: 47 entries.

Show every county Fairfield County page

Ranked by net score

47 of 21,879 entries match

#1Non-typical
217 7/8Josh MathenyFairfield · 2003 · Long Bow
#2Non-typical
203 7/8Richard HutchisonFairfield · 2008 · Long Bow
#3Non-typical
192 7/8Matt DeFazioFairfield · 2003 · Long Bow
#4Non-typical
186 4/8Todd HammondFairfield · 2003 · Long Bow
#5Non-typical
183 1/8Eric WinklerFairfield · 2009 · Long Bow
#6Non-typical
180 5/8Gary BudnickFairfield · 2006 · Long Bow
#7Non-typical
173 2/8Gary BartlettFairfield · 2004 · Long Bow
#8Typical
171 4/8Kirk SmithFairfield · 2003 · Long Bow
#9Typical
170 6/8John SimsFairfield · 2009 · Long Bow
#10Typical
170 1/8Kirk SmithFairfield · 2002 · Long Bow

#	Hunter	Score	Year	County	Weapon	Rack
#11	Robert W Markowski Lancaster	167 3/8	2007	Fairfield	Long Bow	Non-Typical
#12	Kevin Beery Carroll	166 4/8	2003	Fairfield	Long Bow	Non-Typical
#13	Kenneth D Green Lancaster	163 6/8	2002	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#14	Ken Kastely Carroll	162 5/8	2001	Fairfield	Long Bow	Non-Typical
#15	Mark Hammond Rushville	160 7/8	2009	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#16	James Sites Lancaster	160 2/8	2006	Fairfield	Long Bow	Non-Typical
#17	Josh Guiler Amanda	159 7/8	2002	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#18	Benton Dean Obetz	156 1/8	2000	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#19	Jadon Hershberger Lancaster	154 4/8	2001	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#20	Robert Strait Lithopolis	154 2/8	2007	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#21	Lou A Weisenstein Pataskala	153 4/8	2003	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#22	Mark Ayers Columbus	153 3/8	2009	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#23	William C Nichols Canal Winchester	153 0/8	2001	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#24	Ted Franklin Pickerington	151 0/8	2004	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#25	Lou A Weisenstein Pataskala	150 6/8	2005	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#26	Kyle Williamson Pickerington	150 0/8	2009	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#27	Thomas E Springer Baltimore	149 6/8	2005	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#28	Darren Brokaw Canal Winchester	148 4/8	2009	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#29	Scott V Dusen Columbus	148 3/8	2004	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#30	Given Ward Gibsonia	146 4/8	2003	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#31	Andrew L Cherryhomes Pickerington	145 2/8	2005	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#32	Kirk Smith Lancaster	145 1/8	2001	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#33	Jesse Dawson Pickerington	145 0/8	2000	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#34	Nathaniel A Weisenstein Pataskala	144 7/8	2003	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#35	Matthew W Woodrum Junction City	144 4/8	2000	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#36	Rodney Oyer Pickerington	143 7/8	2007	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#37	James Stephenson Lancaster	143 3/8	2005	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#38	Ben Farmer Mt Pleasant	143 2/8	2009	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#39	Andrew L Cherryhomes Pickerington	142 3/8	2006	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#40	Ron Haynes Baltimore	141 6/8	2006	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#41	Ron Claytor Grove City	141 4/8	2003	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#42	Dewey Workman Columbus	141 2/8	2002	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#43	Dwayne Tackett Marion	140 6/8	2002	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#44	Garry Miller Thornville	140 5/8	2002	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#45	Josh Dixon Junction City	140 3/8	2009	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#46	Christopher L Dalrymple Reynoldsburg	140 1/8	2003	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical
#47	Herbert L VanFossen Lancaster	140 1/8	2007	Fairfield	Long Bow	Typical

Page views are counted with Vercel Analytics. No ads, and we don't sell your data. Privacy · Terms