Buckeye Big Buck Club · ODNR record book
Ohio big buck records
Every officially scored buck in Ohio’s record book, ranked by net score. Typical bucks start at 140 inches, non-typical at 160.
Source: Buckeye Big Buck Club record book (ODNR), retrieved Sep 15, 2026. How the records work
Where they were taken
Carroll County: 53 entries.
Ranked by net score
53 of 21,879 entries match · page 1 of 2
- #1Non-typical186 3/8Chuck Caldwell
- #2Typical184 1/8Timothy E Treadway
- #3Non-typical181 1/8James W Carter
- #4Non-typical178 6/8Michael Wharton
- #5Non-typical178 4/8Merle Edie
- #6Non-typical175 5/8Bruce E Weisburn
- #7Typical172 1/8Randy S Mulheim
- #8Typical169 6/8Paul Waderker
- #9Non-typical169 6/8Paul Waechter
- #10Non-typical169 4/8Shane Elifritz
| # | Hunter | Score | Year | County |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #11 | Lonnie Brady Minerva | 168 0/8 | 1982 | Carroll |
| #12 | Stan Bright Carrollton | 166 2/8 | 1981 | Carroll |
| #13 | Kenneth L Stoddard East Sparta | 165 3/8 | 1988 | Carroll |
| #14 | Dale Lowe Canton | 164 6/8 | 1984 | Carroll |
| #15 | Paul George Canal Fulton | 164 2/8 | 1980 | Carroll |
| #16 | David P Marcus Jewett | 161 7/8 | 1982 | Carroll |
| #17 | Randall T Waggoner Malvern | 161 4/8 | 1988 | Carroll |
| #18 | Glenn Dye Amsterdam | 159 7/8 | 1985 | Carroll |
| #19 | Mark Irwin Minerva | 159 2/8 | 1989 | Carroll |
| #20 | William E Brackin Carrollton | 158 6/8 | 1980 | Carroll |
| #21 | Carl A Smith Amsterdam | 158 4/8 | 1988 | Carroll |
| #22 | Larry Englehart Minerva | 157 4/8 | 1984 | Carroll |
| #23 | Richard Eick Carrollton | 157 0/8 | 1985 | Carroll |
| #24 | Gene Smart Dover | 155 3/8 | 1983 | Carroll |
| #25 | George Pazel Boardman | 154 3/8 | 1986 | Carroll |
| #26 | Glenn W Dye Amsterdam | 151 0/8 | 1987 | Carroll |
| #27 | Jeff Nign Carrollton | 151 0/8 | 1987 | Carroll |
| #28 | William O Bricker Louisville | 151 0/8 | 1983 | Carroll |
| #29 | Jeffery Stewart Mingo Junction | 150 2/8 | 1985 | Carroll |
| #30 | Lee W Koch North Olmsted | 147 6/8 | 1988 | Carroll |
| #31 | Williard E Talkington Amsterdam | 147 6/8 | 1989 | Carroll |
| #32 | Dudley D Carpenter Amsterdam | 147 4/8 | 1983 | Carroll |
| #33 | Robert W Brewer Salineville | 147 4/8 | 1986 | Carroll |
| #34 | Arlus M Maley Canton | 147 2/8 | 1984 | Carroll |
| #35 | James Moore Scio | 147 2/8 | 1988 | Carroll |
| #36 | Leonard A Ketchum Carrollton | 145 7/8 | 1980 | Carroll |
| #37 | Martin S Albright Malvern | 145 1/8 | 1984 | Carroll |
| #38 | Donald T Barwick Canton | 145 0/8 | 1985 | Carroll |
| #39 | Robert J Sickafoose Magnolia | 144 7/8 | 1989 | Carroll |
| #40 | Keith O Hanson East Liverpool | 144 2/8 | 1980 | Carroll |
| #41 | Robert J Hill Stow | 143 7/8 | 1986 | Carroll |
| #42 | Robert E Hall East Rochester | 143 6/8 | 1983 | Carroll |
| #43 | Sam Bagozzi Sherrodsville | 143 5/8 | 1985 | Carroll |
| #44 | James Carter Mechanicstown | 143 4/8 | 1982 | Carroll |
| #45 | David Meola North Canton | 143 2/8 | 1981 | Carroll |
| #46 | Nathan S Engstrom Akron | 143 1/8 | 1989 | Carroll |
| #47 | Glenn Dye Amsterdam | 142 1/8 | 1980 | Carroll |
| #48 | Annette M Gamble Scio | 141 3/8 | 1981 | Carroll |
| #49 | Larry Englehart Minerva | 141 3/8 | 1986 | Carroll |
| #50 | James Moore Scio | 140 6/8 | 1985 | Carroll |