TB
TrophyBook
Ohio harvest intel
Buckeye Big Buck Club · ODNR record book

Ohio typical whitetail records

Every typical buck in the Buckeye Big Buck Club record book, ranked by net score. Typical racks only (minimum 140 inches).

Source: Buckeye Big Buck Club record book (ODNR), retrieved Sep 15, 2026. How the records work

WeaponAllModern ShotgunLong BowCrossbowMuzzleloaderStraight-Walled RifleHand Gun
DecadeAll2020s2010s2000s1990s1980sBefore 1980
Adams: 18 entriesAllen: 13 entriesAshland: 31 entriesAshtabula: 13 entriesAthens: 22 entriesAuglaize: 6 entriesBelmont: 24 entriesBrown: 12 entriesButler: 10 entriesCarroll: 22 entriesChampaign: 17 entriesClark: 15 entriesClermont: 17 entriesClinton: 11 entriesColumbiana: 22 entriesCoshocton: 32 entriesCrawford: 6 entriesCuyahoga: 0 entriesDarke: 9 entriesDefiance: 18 entriesDelaware: 9 entriesErie: 7 entriesFairfield: 25 entriesFayette: 5 entriesFranklin: 13 entriesFulton: 4 entriesGallia: 25 entriesGeauga: 7 entriesGreene: 16 entriesGuernsey: 31 entriesHamilton: 9 entriesHancock: 15 entriesHardin: 14 entriesHarrison: 7 entriesHenry: 7 entriesHighland: 25 entriesHocking: 24 entriesHolmes: 19 entriesHuron: 13 entriesJackson: 12 entriesJefferson: 30 entriesKnox: 25 entriesLake: 2 entriesLawrence: 9 entriesLicking: 53 entriesLogan: 26 entriesLorain: 12 entriesLucas: 0 entriesMadison: 13 entriesMahoning: 8 entriesMarion: 10 entriesMedina: 15 entriesMeigs: 22 entriesMercer: 4 entriesMiami: 20 entriesMonroe: 8 entriesMontgomery: 3 entriesMorgan: 34 entriesMorrow: 16 entriesMuskingum: 29 entriesNoble: 17 entriesOttawa: 5 entriesPaulding: 9 entriesPerry: 32 entriesPickaway: 7 entriesPike: 18 entriesPortage: 6 entriesPreble: 17 entriesPutnam: 2 entriesRichland: 27 entriesRoss: 44 entriesSandusky: 10 entriesScioto: 10 entriesSeneca: 11 entriesShelby: 11 entriesStark: 7 entriesSummit: 1 entryTrumbull: 22 entriesTuscarawas: 25 entriesUnion: 13 entriesVan Wert: 7 entriesVinton: 17 entriesWarren: 16 entriesWashington: 29 entriesWayne: 12 entriesWilliams: 10 entriesWood: 13 entriesWyandot: 25 entries

Where they were taken

Carroll County: 22 entries.

Show every countyCarroll County page

  1. Licking53
  2. Ross44
  3. Morgan34
  4. Coshocton32
  5. Perry32
  6. Ashland31
  7. Guernsey31
  8. Jefferson30

Ranked by net score

22 of 18,061 entries match

  1. #1Typical
    176 1/8Don A PontonesCarroll · 2004 · Muzzleloader
  2. #2Typical
    168 7/8Eric GandeeCarroll · 2002 · Muzzleloader
  3. #3Typical
    161 7/8Clifford RandolphCarroll · 2002 · Muzzleloader
  4. #4Typical
    158 4/8Carl A SmithCarroll · 1988 · Muzzleloader
  5. #5Typical
    157 3/8Santo V GennaroCarroll · 2000 · Muzzleloader
  6. #6Typical
    154 3/8David A GrimesCarroll · 2002 · Muzzleloader
  7. #7Typical
    154 3/8George PazelCarroll · 1986 · Muzzleloader
  8. #8Typical
    150 6/8Jake WilsonCarroll · 2012 · Muzzleloader
  9. #9Typical
    150 1/8Clifford RobertsCarroll · 2023 · Muzzleloader
  10. #10Typical
    149 7/8John S AyersCarroll · 2006 · Muzzleloader
#HunterScoreYearCountyWeapon
#11Rick Nicholas
Malvern
148 6/82011CarrollMuzzleloader
#12Jeffrey E Robertson
Lindhurst
148 3/82002CarrollMuzzleloader
#13Williard E Talkington
Amsterdam
147 6/81989CarrollMuzzleloader
#14Clifford Roberts
Minerva
145 4/82017CarrollMuzzleloader
#15Martin S Albright
Malvern
145 1/81984CarrollMuzzleloader
#16Brock Albaugh
Carrollton
144 6/82010CarrollMuzzleloader
#17Brittanie N Poole
Magnolia
143 7/82007CarrollMuzzleloader
#18Richard Stone
Amsterdam
143 5/82011CarrollMuzzleloader
#19Peggy Stacho
Medina
142 7/82022CarrollMuzzleloader
#20James A Mayle
Louisville
142 1/81996CarrollMuzzleloader
#21Jeff Bigler
Mineral City
141 5/82002CarrollMuzzleloader
#22Brian Coler
Youngstown
141 3/82012CarrollMuzzleloader

Page views are counted with Vercel Analytics. No ads, and we don't sell your data. Privacy · Terms

Ohio typical whitetail records — TrophyBook