Buckeye Big Buck Club · ODNR record book

Ohio typical whitetail records

Every typical buck in the Buckeye Big Buck Club record book, ranked by net score. Typical racks only (minimum 140 inches).

Source: Buckeye Big Buck Club record book (ODNR), retrieved Sep 15, 2026. How the records work

WeaponAll Modern Shotgun Long Bow Crossbow Muzzleloader Straight-Walled Rifle Hand Gun

DecadeAll 2020s 2010s 2000s 1990s 1980s Before 1980

Where they were taken

Butler County: 112 entries.

Show every county Butler County page

Ranked by net score

112 of 18,061 entries match · page 2 of 3

#	Hunter	Score	Year	County	Weapon
#51	Nathan T Medcalf Germantown	154 6/8	1999	Butler	Modern Shotgun
#52	Benjamin M Whitaker Hamilton	154 3/8	2009	Butler	Modern Shotgun
#53	Chris Wyatt Fairfield	154 3/8	1999	Butler	Long Bow
#54	Bill Barnhart Trenton	153 7/8	2010	Butler	Crossbow
#55	Doug Caddell Hamilton	153 5/8	2001	Butler	Muzzleloader
#56	Dan Curtis Okeana	153 1/8	2008	Butler	Muzzleloader
#57	Andrew Bulach Waynesville	153 0/8	2016	Butler	Long Bow
#58	Brandon Watkins Somerville	152 5/8	2014	Butler	Long Bow
#59	Kevin Owens Westchester	152 3/8	2010	Butler	Crossbow
#60	Brian Arnold Hamilton	152 0/8	2009	Butler	Crossbow
#61	Buell Harris Hamilton	152 0/8	2002	Butler	Long Bow
#62	Tim Dalton Germantown	152 0/8	1990	Butler	Modern Shotgun
#63	Mark Ward Oxford	151 1/8	1989	Butler	Muzzleloader
#64	James Witt West Chester	151 0/8	2010	Butler	Crossbow
#65	Mike Gibbs Camden	150 7/8	1992	Butler	Long Bow
#66	Rick Mills Middletown	150 2/8	1998	Butler	Modern Shotgun
#67	Jeff Withrow Hamilton	149 6/8	2006	Butler	Crossbow
#68	Stephen Mattfield Monroe	149 6/8	2000	Butler	Crossbow
#69	Ross Blaine Trenton	149 5/8	1987	Butler	Modern Shotgun
#70	Randy R Buttery College Corner	149 4/8	1992	Butler	Modern Shotgun
#71	Sam Collins Middletown	149 0/8	1992	Butler	Crossbow
#72	Mark Lagedrost Fairfield	148 4/8	2010	Butler	Crossbow
#73	Jim Phelps Hamilton	148 3/8	1990	Butler	Long Bow
#74	Bob Selby Middletown	148 0/8	2004	Butler	Crossbow
#75	James King Sommerville	148 0/8	2011	Butler	Crossbow
#76	John P Carroll Hamilton	147 3/8	2009	Butler	Long Bow
#77	David Underwood Collinsville	147 1/8	1989	Butler	Modern Shotgun
#78	Bill J McIntire Middletown	146 6/8	1987	Butler	Modern Shotgun
#79	Edward Menkhaus Okeana	146 3/8	2017	Butler	Long Bow
#80	Greg Grupenhof Hamilton	146 3/8	2006	Butler	Crossbow
#81	Bob Wood Cincinnati	146 2/8	2015	Butler	Long Bow
#82	Brett Bueltel Hamilton	146 2/8	2012	Butler	Long Bow
#83	Kenny Butler Trenton	145 7/8	1991	Butler	Long Bow
#84	Dale Baumann Hamilton	145 6/8	2006	Butler	Crossbow
#85	James Keith Middletown	145 5/8	2005	Butler	Crossbow
#86	Carl Armstrong Trenton	145 4/8	2005	Butler	Muzzleloader
#87	Paul J Ebers Cincinnati	145 3/8	1993	Butler	Long Bow
#88	Greg Fathing Oxford	145 2/8	1991	Butler	Long Bow
#89	Scott Wilson Franklin	145 1/8	2009	Butler	Long Bow
#90	James A Center Middletown	145 0/8	1986	Butler	Modern Shotgun
#91	Sam Baumann West Chester	144 7/8	2008	Butler	Long Bow
#92	Ed Menkhaus Hamilton	144 5/8	2002	Butler	Modern Shotgun
#93	Jennifer Wood Cinti	144 1/8	2019	Butler	Long Bow
#94	Dale Baumann Hamilton	144 0/8	2004	Butler	Muzzleloader
#95	Bob Light Fairfield	143 6/8	1985	Butler	Modern Shotgun
#96	Gary Gamble Hamilton	143 6/8	2000	Butler	Muzzleloader
#97	Steven O'Brien Hamilton	143 1/8	2019	Butler	Long Bow
#98	Joshua Martin Middletown	142 7/8	2002	Butler	Long Bow
#99	Mark Weingartner West Chester	142 5/8	2000	Butler	Long Bow
#100	Jeff Woodall Cincinnati	142 0/8	2000	Butler	Modern Shotgun

Page views are counted with Vercel Analytics. No ads, and we don't sell your data. Privacy · Terms