Buckeye Big Buck Club · ODNR record book
Ohio typical whitetail records
Every typical buck in the Buckeye Big Buck Club record book, ranked by net score. Typical racks only (minimum 140 inches).
Source: Buckeye Big Buck Club record book (ODNR), retrieved Sep 15, 2026. How the records work
Where they were taken
Athens County: 102 entries.
Ranked by net score
102 of 18,061 entries match · page 1 of 3
- #1Typical175 5/8Jerry Dexter
- #2Typical174 6/8Alex Couladis
- #3Typical169 0/8Jonathan Dailey
- #4Typical168 2/8Jeff Jacobs
- #5Typical167 6/8Donnie Stevens
- #6Typical165 7/8Mike Keith
- #7Typical165 0/8Rod Nutter
- #8Typical163 3/8Carl Thompson
- #9Typical163 3/8Jim Castle
- #10Typical161 6/8Roger Conner
| # | Hunter | Score | Year | County |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #11 | Michael V Schaffer Mentor | 161 4/8 | 2000 | Athens |
| #12 | Randy Hilty Powell | 161 2/8 | 2004 | Athens |
| #13 | Mike A Rex Athens | 161 1/8 | 2004 | Athens |
| #14 | Greg Linscott Chillicothe | 158 1/8 | 2003 | Athens |
| #15 | Mike A Thomas Coolville | 157 7/8 | 2004 | Athens |
| #16 | Bob Antle Athens | 157 5/8 | 2000 | Athens |
| #17 | James M Milligan Columbus | 157 2/8 | 2001 | Athens |
| #18 | Bob Weffler Athens | 157 0/8 | 2004 | Athens |
| #19 | Calvin Jordan Guysville | 157 0/8 | 2002 | Athens |
| #20 | Mike Cuckler Athens | 157 0/8 | 2004 | Athens |
| #21 | Troulies Ledbetter West Jefferson | 156 3/8 | 2002 | Athens |
| #22 | Brandon Maiden Nelsonville | 155 4/8 | 2001 | Athens |
| #23 | Brian K Dowler Nelsonville | 155 1/8 | 2007 | Athens |
| #24 | Joe Cordi Olmsted Twshp | 155 0/8 | 2009 | Athens |
| #25 | Chris Callehan Lima | 154 6/8 | 2008 | Athens |
| #26 | Greg Smith Chauncey | 154 6/8 | 2002 | Athens |
| #27 | Robert Heightland Athens | 153 0/8 | 2000 | Athens |
| #28 | Justin A Williams Coolville | 152 7/8 | 2006 | Athens |
| #29 | John B Seelhorst Fayetteville | 151 6/8 | 2001 | Athens |
| #30 | Larry Lightner Guysville | 151 6/8 | 2009 | Athens |
| #31 | Jeffrey J Johnson Reedsville | 151 5/8 | 2002 | Athens |
| #32 | Dale A VanHorn McComb | 151 2/8 | 2000 | Athens |
| #33 | Eddie Hart Coolville | 151 0/8 | 2006 | Athens |
| #34 | Josh Sherrick Lima | 150 7/8 | 2002 | Athens |
| #35 | Mike Cuckler Athens | 150 7/8 | 2009 | Athens |
| #36 | Claude Cunningham Athens | 150 6/8 | 2001 | Athens |
| #37 | Mark Valentine Reynoldsburg | 150 4/8 | 2000 | Athens |
| #38 | Michael D Cuckler Athens | 150 4/8 | 2002 | Athens |
| #39 | John R Hurd Nelsonville | 150 1/8 | 2003 | Athens |
| #40 | Sue McBride Columbus | 149 7/8 | 2008 | Athens |
| #41 | Norm Troyer Plain City | 149 6/8 | 2000 | Athens |
| #42 | John K Sheffield Blacklick | 149 5/8 | 2008 | Athens |
| #43 | Brian Martin Nelsonville | 149 4/8 | 2004 | Athens |
| #44 | Steven Wilson Hilliard | 149 2/8 | 2002 | Athens |
| #45 | Troy E Goins Reynoldsburg | 149 2/8 | 2002 | Athens |
| #46 | Jacob Perkins Nelsonville | 149 1/8 | 2006 | Athens |
| #47 | Mike Cuckler Athens | 149 0/8 | 2003 | Athens |
| #48 | Ken Samsss Athens | 148 7/8 | 2002 | Athens |
| #49 | Chuck Hartley Trimble | 148 3/8 | 2006 | Athens |
| #50 | Michael C Markins New Marshfield | 148 3/8 | 2001 | Athens |