Buckeye Big Buck Club · ODNR record book
Ohio non-typical whitetail records
Every non-typical buck in the Buckeye Big Buck Club record book, ranked by net score. Non-typical racks only (minimum 160 inches).
Source: Buckeye Big Buck Club record book (ODNR), retrieved Sep 15, 2026. How the records work
Ranked by net score
398 of 3,818 entries match · page 1 of 8
- #1Non-typical234 1/8Gregory Hunt
- #2Non-typical231 4/8Roger D Lewis
- #3Non-typical230 5/8Eli A Hershberger
- #4Non-typical224 7/8Aaron Barlow
- #5Non-typical222 4/8Jonathan K Hale
- #6Non-typical216 7/8Lance Mitchell
- #7Non-typical214 7/8Kevin Brown
- #8Non-typical214 3/8Brian Hayslip
- #9Non-typical211 3/8Jon A Byers
- #10Non-typical211 2/8Charles W Tennant
| # | Hunter | Score | Year | County |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #11 | Lemuel Brown Rayland | 210 5/8 | 2009 | Jefferson |
| #12 | Jonathan Mathys Bellefontaine | 209 2/8 | 2009 | Logan |
| #13 | Nicholas D Fauber Hillsboro | 209 1/8 | 2008 | Highland |
| #14 | Eddie Hunter Hillsboro | 209 0/8 | 2000 | Highland |
| #15 | Robert Thompson Lancaster | 208 1/8 | 2007 | Fairfield |
| #16 | Jerry Johnson Alliance | 207 2/8 | 2006 | Carroll |
| #17 | Mike Warnock Clarksville | 206 5/8 | 2003 | Clinton |
| #18 | Gene Smith Blue Rock | 206 4/8 | 2008 | Muskingum |
| #19 | Harold Macblain Cambridge | 206 2/8 | 2007 | Guernsey |
| #20 | James Cox Hillsboro | 205 7/8 | 2009 | Highland |
| #21 | Robert H Creel Bucyrus | 204 5/8 | 2002 | Crawford |
| #22 | Thomas R West Boardman | 204 5/8 | 2006 | Mahoning |
| #23 | Joseph F Wayne Johnstown | 203 6/8 | 2007 | Licking |
| #24 | Josh Coffey St Marys | 203 4/8 | 2007 | Auglaize |
| #25 | G D Mitchell Lucas | 202 6/8 | 2004 | Richland |
| #26 | Glen Webb Xenia | 202 5/8 | 2004 | Greene |
| #27 | Jeff Waldnig Mechanicsburg | 202 3/8 | 2004 | Champaign |
| #28 | Shawn M Lohr Bellville | 201 1/8 | 2009 | Morrow |
| #29 | Douglas M May Massillon | 200 6/8 | 2004 | Stark |
| #30 | Shawn Gaines Hilliard | 200 5/8 | 2005 | Delaware |
| #31 | Ron Preston Frankfurt | 200 4/8 | 2006 | Ross |
| #32 | Jason Williams McArthur | 200 2/8 | 2007 | Vinton |
| #33 | Eddie E Mayle Fairmont | 199 6/8 | 2003 | Carroll |
| #34 | Frank R Smith Apple Creek | 199 5/8 | 2001 | Wayne |
| #35 | Brandon A Klinginsmith Atwater | 199 4/8 | 2009 | Portage |
| #36 | Allen E Brooks Andover | 199 3/8 | 2003 | Ashtabula |
| #37 | Jeremy R Traxler Upper Sandusky | 199 2/8 | 2002 | Marion |
| #38 | Michael J Martin Logan | 199 1/8 | 2000 | Hocking |
| #39 | Terry Garee Heath | 199 1/8 | 2002 | Licking |
| #40 | Henry R Jackson Columbus | 198 7/8 | 2003 | Licking |
| #41 | James T Hlay Westerville | 198 7/8 | 2002 | Knox |
| #42 | Rusty Russell Thornville | 198 1/8 | 2005 | Fairfield |
| #43 | James C Carpenter Mansfield | 198 0/8 | 2001 | Richland |
| #44 | Brian Martin Waynesville | 196 1/8 | 2007 | Vinton |
| #45 | Jake Lindsey Granville | 196 1/8 | 2007 | Licking |
| #46 | Steve Bradley Newark | 195 7/8 | 2006 | Licking |
| #47 | Mike T Allerding Loudonville | 195 5/8 | 2000 | Holmes |
| #48 | Nick Thompson Hamersville | 195 5/8 | 2008 | Clermont |
| #49 | Phil Schulze Sidney | 195 3/8 | 2003 | Shelby |
| #50 | Brandon J Stevens Mansfield | 195 2/8 | 2003 | Richland |