Buckeye Big Buck Club · ODNR record book

Ohio non-typical whitetail records

Every non-typical buck in the Buckeye Big Buck Club record book, ranked by net score. Non-typical racks only (minimum 160 inches).

Source: Buckeye Big Buck Club record book (ODNR), retrieved Sep 15, 2026. How the records work

WeaponAll Modern Shotgun Crossbow Long Bow Muzzleloader Straight-Walled Rifle Hand Gun

DecadeAll 2020s 2010s 2000s 1990s 1980s Before 1980

Where they were taken

Tap a county to see its bucks.

Ranked by net score

282 of 3,818 entries match · page 1 of 6

#1Non-typical
304 6/8Michael BeattyGreene · 2000 · Long Bow
#2Non-typical
244 0/8Jeffrey T KaserHolmes · 2003 · Long Bow
#3Non-typical
240 4/8Jason McClinticRoss · 2009 · Long Bow
#4Non-typical
219 6/8Aaron IrelandHocking · 2004 · Long Bow
#5Non-typical
219 5/8Tim R KingGuernsey · 2005 · Long Bow
#6Non-typical
218 6/8Mike A RexAthens · 2005 · Long Bow
#7Non-typical
217 7/8Josh MathenyFairfield · 2003 · Long Bow
#8Non-typical
216 0/8Rodney StumboHuron · 2009 · Long Bow
#9Non-typical
215 3/8Jeff ClemsonAshtabula · 2001 · Long Bow
#10Non-typical
213 0/8Eric MorrowMorgan · 2009 · Long Bow

#	Hunter	Score	Year	County	Weapon
#11	Chris Lepley Mount Vernon	212 5/8	2001	Licking	Long Bow
#12	Don Mitcham London	211 1/8	2005	Madison	Long Bow
#13	Kerry Kerkhoff Patriot	207 1/8	2003	Clermont	Long Bow
#14	Rick Hildebrand Geneva	206 3/8	2002	Ashtabula	Long Bow
#15	Wynn A Brinker Pemberville	205 6/8	2001	Wood	Long Bow
#16	Bruce E Lane Columbus	204 3/8	2009	Tuscarawas	Long Bow
#17	Lonnie J Brake Cardington	204 2/8	2003	Morrow	Long Bow
#18	Ronald J Ault Richmond	204 1/8	2002	Jefferson	Long Bow
#19	James J Gazso Willowick	204 0/8	2004	Cuyahoga	Long Bow
#20	Richard Hutchison Baltimore	203 7/8	2008	Fairfield	Long Bow
#21	Colin Hatoman Centerburg	203 5/8	2009	Delaware	Long Bow
#22	David A Nichols Johnstown	202 1/8	2007	Licking	Long Bow
#23	Kevin L Bussert Carroll	201 7/8	2009	—	Long Bow
#24	Justin Williamson Warsaw	200 6/8	2006	Coshocton	Long Bow
#25	Kenneth Anderson Lodi	200 6/8	2001	Medina	Long Bow
#26	Rick Elliott Bellefontaine	200 5/8	2006	Logan	Long Bow
#27	Robert C Sargent Waynesville	200 5/8	2002	Clinton	Long Bow
#28	Darren Sapp Piketon	199 4/8	2002	Pike	Long Bow
#29	Darin Howell Wingett Run	198 6/8	2008	Washington	Long Bow
#30	Robert Wingeier Granville	198 6/8	2008	Licking	Long Bow
#31	Nicole Wolf Chillicothe	198 4/8	2005	Ross	Long Bow
#32	Jack Satterfield Langsville	198 0/8	2000	Meigs	Long Bow
#33	Michael Amsbaugh Marysville	198 0/8	2000	Union	Long Bow
#34	Charles L McHenry Goshen	196 7/8	2002	Clermont	Long Bow
#35	Gary L Fowler Loudonville	195 7/8	2005	Wayne	Long Bow
#36	James A Blevins Corryton	195 7/8	2002	Adams	Long Bow
#37	Jesse Everette Tipp City	195 6/8	2009	Miami	Long Bow
#38	Sam Angle Covington	195 6/8	2008	Miami	Long Bow
#39	Robert Wilson Urbana	195 5/8	2009	Champaign	Long Bow
#40	Martin E Hamm Larue	195 4/8	2007	Marion	Long Bow
#41	Mark Bassler Camden	195 3/8	2006	Preble	Long Bow
#42	Matt A Garvin Cardington	195 3/8	2009	Morrow	Long Bow
#43	Scott Burton Xenia	195 2/8	2008	Greene	Long Bow
#44	Charles Combs Moscow	194 2/8	2003	Clermont	Long Bow
#45	Dennis Bolyard New Straitsville	193 7/8	2008	Hocking	Long Bow
#46	Troy Wrather Port Washington	193 4/8	2005	Tuscarawas	Long Bow
#47	Bill Coe Conover	193 2/8	2008	Champaign	Long Bow
#48	Matt DeFazio Pleasantville	192 7/8	2003	Fairfield	Long Bow
#49	Scott A Boyer Washington C.H.	192 6/8	2000	Fayette	Long Bow
#50	Chris Eldridge Winchester	192 4/8	2003	Adams	Long Bow

Page views are counted with Vercel Analytics. No ads, and we don't sell your data. Privacy · Terms