Buckeye Big Buck Club · ODNR record book
Ohio non-typical whitetail records
Every non-typical buck in the Buckeye Big Buck Club record book, ranked by net score. Non-typical racks only (minimum 160 inches).
Source: Buckeye Big Buck Club record book (ODNR), retrieved Sep 15, 2026. How the records work
Ranked by net score
308 of 3,818 entries match · page 5 of 7
| # | Hunter | Score | Year | County |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #201 | Donald G Davis Wadsworth | 170 1/8 | 2008 | Noble |
| #202 | Wes McMillen Stone Creek | 169 5/8 | 2003 | Tuscarawas |
| #203 | Zach R Singler Georgetown | 169 2/8 | 2007 | Brown |
| #204 | Mark Phalen New Holland | 169 0/8 | 2001 | — |
| #205 | Rod Warnimont Findlay | 169 0/8 | 2007 | Hancock |
| #206 | Scott L Smith Oak Harbor | 169 0/8 | 2003 | Guernsey |
| #207 | Scott Wayt Bellefontaine | 169 0/8 | 2002 | Logan |
| #208 | Tom Smith New Lebon | 168 7/8 | 2006 | Montgomery |
| #209 | Darrell Withrow Van Buren | 168 6/8 | 2005 | Hancock |
| #210 | Gary Carpenter Urbana | 168 5/8 | 2002 | Champaign |
| #211 | Jerry Elliott Canton | 168 3/8 | 2000 | Noble |
| #212 | Johnni Welsh Rutland | 168 3/8 | 2009 | Meigs |
| #213 | Tony Newman Clinton | 168 2/8 | 2008 | Delaware |
| #214 | Dennis Heilman Old Fort | 168 1/8 | 2008 | Seneca |
| #215 | Lee Wise New Paris | 168 1/8 | 2006 | Preble |
| #216 | Fred Oehler Goshen | 168 0/8 | 2007 | Clermont |
| #217 | Tom Stidham Lima | 168 0/8 | 2007 | Allen |
| #218 | Clay Stanger Frankfort | 167 7/8 | 2005 | Ross |
| #219 | Craig Moran Delaware | 167 6/8 | 2005 | Delaware |
| #220 | John May Sunbury | 167 6/8 | 2004 | Delaware |
| #221 | Tony Myers Eaton | 167 6/8 | 2005 | Preble |
| #222 | Gary Canterbury Elyria | 167 5/8 | 2000 | Lorain |
| #223 | Jerry Berry Akron | 167 5/8 | 2003 | Summit |
| #224 | Jim Vorhees Republic | 167 5/8 | 2006 | Seneca |
| #225 | James Locher Lore City | 167 4/8 | 2009 | Guernsey |
| #226 | James V Justice Wheelersburg | 167 4/8 | 2008 | Scioto |
| #227 | Josh Joseph Reynoldsburg | 167 1/8 | 2006 | Licking |
| #228 | Dan Patterson Frankfort | 166 7/8 | 2000 | Ross |
| #229 | Jeff Stethem Pomeroy | 166 6/8 | 2008 | Meigs |
| #230 | David A Cummings Parma | 166 4/8 | 2006 | Medina |
| #231 | George G Smolinski Independence | 166 4/8 | 2003 | Guernsey |
| #232 | Rick Koelsch Sandusky | 166 4/8 | 2004 | Huron |
| #233 | Joseph Minarchek Delaware | 166 3/8 | 2009 | Delaware |
| #234 | Danial Frey Columbus | 166 2/8 | 2004 | Madison |
| #235 | Josh Johnson Centerburg | 166 2/8 | 2001 | Licking |
| #236 | Matt Baird Newcomerstown | 166 2/8 | 2006 | Tuscarawas |
| #237 | Robert DeMay Canton | 166 2/8 | 2005 | Tuscarawas |
| #238 | Sharon Parsons Waterford | 166 2/8 | 2006 | Lucas |
| #239 | Bill Pumphrey Wooster | 166 1/8 | 2007 | Wayne |
| #240 | David Simmons Fredericktown | 166 1/8 | 2000 | Morrow |
| #241 | Matt Buzzard Ashland | 166 1/8 | 2002 | Holmes |
| #242 | Rob Ross St Paris | 166 1/8 | 2006 | Champaign |
| #243 | Ronald W Cline Ravenna | 166 1/8 | 2001 | Muskingum |
| #244 | Jerry W Niemi West Lafayette | 166 0/8 | 2001 | Muskingum |
| #245 | Ivan Myers Oregon | 165 4/8 | 2008 | Lucas |
| #246 | Dean Ward Columbus | 165 2/8 | 2004 | Franklin |
| #247 | Gary E Hammon Defiance | 165 2/8 | 2006 | Defiance |
| #248 | Jack K Clark Delaware | 165 1/8 | 2003 | Delaware |
| #249 | Floyd Detty Frankfort | 165 0/8 | 2004 | Ross |
| #250 | Keith Jones Albany | 165 0/8 | 2007 | Meigs |