Buckeye Big Buck Club · ODNR record book
Ohio non-typical whitetail records
Every non-typical buck in the Buckeye Big Buck Club record book, ranked by net score. Non-typical racks only (minimum 160 inches).
Source: Buckeye Big Buck Club record book (ODNR), retrieved Sep 15, 2026. How the records work
Ranked by net score
259 of 3,818 entries match · page 2 of 6
| # | Hunter | Score | Year | County |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #51 | Dave L Kaylor Elmore | 190 3/8 | 1980 | Ottawa |
| #52 | Brent C Beaman Alger | 190 2/8 | 1983 | Hardin |
| #53 | Henry Bill Marengo | 190 2/8 | 1981 | Morrow |
| #54 | Bruce R Henry Versailles | 190 1/8 | 1986 | Darke |
| #55 | Jeffrey L Cecil Burgoon | 190 0/8 | 1989 | Sandusky |
| #56 | James W Paumier Louisville | 189 7/8 | 1983 | Tuscarawas |
| #57 | Robert Sampsel Killbuck | 189 5/8 | 1982 | Coshocton |
| #58 | Thomas B Campbell Galloway | 189 5/8 | 1987 | Jackson |
| #59 | Walter S Wilson Canton | 189 5/8 | 1981 | Coshocton |
| #60 | Robert Bowersock Ashland | 189 4/8 | 1985 | Ashland |
| #61 | Kip Bookman Glouster | 189 2/8 | 1983 | Hocking |
| #62 | Philip R Frase Smithville | 189 1/8 | 1980 | Coshocton |
| #63 | Bud Hanna Baltimore | 188 3/8 | 1980 | Fairfield |
| #64 | William E West Quaker City | 188 1/8 | 1986 | Noble |
| #65 | Charles E Sowers Frankfort | 187 7/8 | 1981 | Ross |
| #66 | James W Allen Millersport | 187 6/8 | 1986 | Fairfield |
| #67 | Ralph Stallard Sidney | 187 5/8 | 1987 | Logan |
| #68 | Marvin L Davis Waverly | 187 4/8 | 1986 | Pike |
| #69 | Chuck Caldwell Sherrodsville | 186 3/8 | 1980 | Carroll |
| #70 | Steven Miller Blanchester | 186 0/8 | 1987 | Greene |
| #71 | Kenneth Berg Mt. Vernon | 185 5/8 | 1988 | Knox |
| #72 | Russell L Smith Roseville | 185 2/8 | 1986 | Muskingum |
| #73 | Stan Gorney Mogadore | 185 2/8 | 1989 | Coshocton |
| #74 | Dean Billetter Belmont | 184 7/8 | 1981 | Belmont |
| #75 | Daniel L Leffler Negley | 184 6/8 | 1985 | Columbiana |
| #76 | Theodore M Jurgle Warren | 184 6/8 | 1985 | Jefferson |
| #77 | Dan Everidge Fairborn | 184 5/8 | 1983 | Meigs |
| #78 | Dennis Joseph Bowling Green | 184 5/8 | 1988 | Wood |
| #79 | Ronald L Colegrove Pataskala | 184 5/8 | 1980 | Licking |
| #80 | Robert C Barkheimer Navarre | 184 3/8 | 1987 | Noble |
| #81 | Gary Stechschulte Ft. Jennings | 184 2/8 | 1988 | Allen |
| #82 | Mack J Hopkins Blanchester | 184 0/8 | 1983 | Warren |
| #83 | Richard Cady Newark | 184 0/8 | 1988 | Meigs |
| #84 | Thomas J Milery Newark | 183 6/8 | 1983 | Licking |
| #85 | Joseph D Booth Amsterdam | 183 4/8 | 1988 | Jefferson |
| #86 | Martha Sesco Woodstock | 183 4/8 | 1983 | Champaign |
| #87 | Joe Hendershot Powahatan Point | 183 1/8 | 1981 | Monroe |
| #88 | George Burkhart Woodsfield | 183 0/8 | 1984 | Monroe |
| #89 | Gene B Oxley Garfield Heights | 182 1/8 | 1989 | Harrison |
| #90 | Charles Westfall Malta | 181 7/8 | 1985 | Morgan |
| #91 | Dan Frobase Columbus | 181 7/8 | 1983 | Champaign |
| #92 | Charles Lohr Nevada | 181 6/8 | 1985 | Crawford |
| #93 | Dyson Massengill Circleville | 181 5/8 | 1982 | Muskingum |
| #94 | Randall Mizen Tiffin | 181 5/8 | 1988 | Seneca |
| #95 | Steve D Underwood Newark | 181 5/8 | 1984 | Licking |
| #96 | Tim Mathews Newcomerstown | 181 5/8 | 1988 | Tuscarawas |
| #97 | David Edgell Sardis | 181 2/8 | 1988 | Monroe |
| #98 | Brad Smith Newark | 181 1/8 | 1987 | Licking |
| #99 | James W Carter Mechanicstown | 181 1/8 | 1981 | Carroll |
| #100 | David G Mann Lisbon | 181 0/8 | 1983 | Columbiana |