Buckeye Big Buck Club · ODNR record book

Ohio non-typical whitetail records

Every non-typical buck in the Buckeye Big Buck Club record book, ranked by net score. Non-typical racks only (minimum 160 inches).

Source: Buckeye Big Buck Club record book (ODNR), retrieved Sep 15, 2026. How the records work

WeaponAll Modern Shotgun Crossbow Long Bow Muzzleloader Straight-Walled Rifle Hand Gun

DecadeAll 2020s 2010s 2000s 1990s 1980s Before 1980

Where they were taken

Tap a county to see its bucks.

Ranked by net score

50 of 3,818 entries match

#1Non-typical
246 0/8Ronald K OsborneMahoning · 1986 · Long Bow
#2Non-typical
207 0/8Tad E CrawfordStark · 1987 · Long Bow
#3Non-typical
194 5/8Dick BayerGuernsey · 1985 · Long Bow
#4Non-typical
192 3/8Ralph E PhippsUnion · 1982 · Long Bow
#5Non-typical
191 1/8Michael E HoffmanCrawford · 1988 · Long Bow
#6Non-typical
190 4/8John McGeeLicking · 1982 · Long Bow
#7Non-typical
190 0/8Allen JaworskiGuernsey · 1989 · Long Bow
#8Non-typical
189 4/8Dan SeymourRoss · 1987 · Long Bow
#9Non-typical
186 6/8Tom DeweesPortage · 1982 · Long Bow
#10Non-typical
186 2/8Steven J GuessFayette · 1984 · Long Bow

#	Hunter	Score	Year	County	Weapon
#11	Berry W Bennington West Union	185 6/8	1982	Adams	Long Bow
#12	Terry L Paxton Junction City	185 5/8	1989	Licking	Long Bow
#13	Dan Butler Belmont	185 3/8	1987	Belmont	Long Bow
#14	Herman Rice Wooster	185 3/8	1989	Wayne	Long Bow
#15	Bill Cunningham Negley	183 5/8	1989	Columbiana	Long Bow
#16	Floyd J Detty Frankfort	183 5/8	1985	Ross	Long Bow
#17	Jack Watkins New Straitsville	181 7/8	1980	Hocking	Long Bow
#18	Don J Maselli Columbus	180 1/8	1980	Wyandot	Long Bow
#19	Larry Ashbrook Cincinnati	179 6/8	1981	Hamilton	Long Bow
#20	Jack Taylor Troy	179 3/8	1984	Miami	Long Bow
#21	Ron E Murphy Delaware	177 6/8	1983	Delaware	Long Bow
#22	Robert Bowmar Sunbury	177 5/8	1980	Delaware	Long Bow
#23	Chester A Alexander Milan	177 3/8	1989	Erie	Long Bow
#24	William Bierbaugh London	177 3/8	1989	Madison	Long Bow
#25	Donald Quick Columbus	176 0/8	1984	Knox	Long Bow
#26	Curt Davis West Alexandria	175 7/8	1988	Preble	Long Bow
#27	Bruce Bagshall Hillsboro	175 0/8	1987	Highland	Long Bow
#28	Leroy Thompson Xenia	173 7/8	1982	Greene	Long Bow
#29	Jeffery D Barnhart Whitehall	173 4/8	1989	Franklin	Long Bow
#30	Daniel T Fortney Lorain	171 3/8	1988	Lorain	Long Bow
#31	James J Young Cleveland	170 6/8	1986	Tuscarawas	Long Bow
#32	Joseph Dombroski Westerville	170 6/8	1988	Franklin	Long Bow
#33	Brian Morrison Reynoldsburg	170 3/8	1987	Fairfield	Long Bow
#34	Lloyd E Evans Westerville	168 1/8	1988	Franklin	Long Bow
#35	Randy Johnson Lyndon	168 1/8	1981	Ross	Long Bow
#36	Randal Jones Mt. Gilead	167 5/8	1980	Morrow	Long Bow
#37	Craig A Slifko Cambridge	165 6/8	1987	Guernsey	Long Bow
#38	Kenneth L Stoddard East Sparta	165 3/8	1988	Carroll	Long Bow
#39	Thomas Goldson Loveland	164 6/8	1989	Warren	Long Bow
#40	Jerry W Bennett Dover	164 3/8	1982	Tuscarawas	Long Bow
#41	Steve Smith Upper Sandusky	164 1/8	1989	Wyandot	Long Bow
#42	Earle Thomas Clarington	164 0/8	1988	Monroe	Long Bow
#43	Dean P Neff Greenville	163 0/8	1987	—	Long Bow
#44	Mike Ferrell Coolville	162 7/8	1982	Washington	Long Bow
#45	Richard Morgan Killbuck	162 0/8	1987	Coshocton	Long Bow
#46	Orville Kiger Granville	161 7/8	1988	Licking	Long Bow
#47	William Pitts Beloit	160 7/8	1984	Mahoning	Long Bow
#48	Bill Meyer Zanesville	160 2/8	1987	Muskingum	Long Bow
#49	Brian Dew Powell	160 1/8	1989	Knox	Long Bow
#50	David L Tice Wellsville	160 1/8	1987	Columbiana	Long Bow

Page views are counted with Vercel Analytics. No ads, and we don't sell your data. Privacy · Terms