TB
TrophyBook
Ohio harvest intel
Buckeye Big Buck Club · ODNR record book

Ohio non-typical whitetail records

Every non-typical buck in the Buckeye Big Buck Club record book, ranked by net score. Non-typical racks only (minimum 160 inches).

Source: Buckeye Big Buck Club record book (ODNR), retrieved Sep 15, 2026. How the records work

WeaponAllModern ShotgunCrossbowLong BowMuzzleloaderStraight-Walled RifleHand Gun
DecadeAll2020s2010s2000s1990s1980sBefore 1980
Adams: 18 entriesAllen: 3 entriesAshland: 31 entriesAshtabula: 20 entriesAthens: 32 entriesAuglaize: 11 entriesBelmont: 20 entriesBrown: 15 entriesButler: 7 entriesCarroll: 33 entriesChampaign: 14 entriesClark: 6 entriesClermont: 14 entriesClinton: 19 entriesColumbiana: 21 entriesCoshocton: 46 entriesCrawford: 16 entriesCuyahoga: 0 entriesDarke: 8 entriesDefiance: 6 entriesDelaware: 20 entriesErie: 7 entriesFairfield: 33 entriesFayette: 7 entriesFranklin: 10 entriesFulton: 6 entriesGallia: 16 entriesGeauga: 7 entriesGreene: 13 entriesGuernsey: 29 entriesHamilton: 3 entriesHancock: 9 entriesHardin: 18 entriesHarrison: 23 entriesHenry: 5 entriesHighland: 28 entriesHocking: 18 entriesHolmes: 20 entriesHuron: 18 entriesJackson: 23 entriesJefferson: 29 entriesKnox: 31 entriesLake: 3 entriesLawrence: 8 entriesLicking: 65 entriesLogan: 15 entriesLorain: 18 entriesLucas: 4 entriesMadison: 7 entriesMahoning: 20 entriesMarion: 12 entriesMedina: 8 entriesMeigs: 17 entriesMercer: 3 entriesMiami: 3 entriesMonroe: 10 entriesMontgomery: 3 entriesMorgan: 18 entriesMorrow: 27 entriesMuskingum: 44 entriesNoble: 25 entriesOttawa: 2 entriesPaulding: 8 entriesPerry: 24 entriesPickaway: 15 entriesPike: 15 entriesPortage: 10 entriesPreble: 9 entriesPutnam: 2 entriesRichland: 23 entriesRoss: 35 entriesSandusky: 9 entriesScioto: 14 entriesSeneca: 13 entriesShelby: 6 entriesStark: 9 entriesSummit: 2 entriesTrumbull: 14 entriesTuscarawas: 40 entriesUnion: 7 entriesVan Wert: 1 entryVinton: 23 entriesWarren: 3 entriesWashington: 26 entriesWayne: 12 entriesWilliams: 9 entriesWood: 10 entriesWyandot: 18 entries

Where they were taken

Mahoning County: 20 entries.

Show every countyMahoning County page

  1. Licking65
  2. Coshocton46
  3. Muskingum44
  4. Tuscarawas40
  5. Ross35
  6. Carroll33
  7. Fairfield33
  8. Athens32

Ranked by net score

20 of 3,818 entries match

  1. #1Non-typical
    242 3/8David L KlemmMahoning · 1980 · Modern Shotgun
  2. #2Non-typical
    204 5/8Thomas R WestMahoning · 2006 · Modern Shotgun
  3. #3Non-typical
    202 6/8Michael J MahonMahoning · 1993 · Modern Shotgun
  4. #4Non-typical
    193 7/8George StacyMahoning · 1991 · Modern Shotgun
  5. #5Non-typical
    188 7/8Anthony N QuattroMahoning · 1990 · Modern Shotgun
  6. #6Non-typical
    186 1/8Robert SchieleMahoning · 1999 · Modern Shotgun
  7. #7Non-typical
    185 4/8George R BasileMahoning · 2010 · Modern Shotgun
  8. #8Non-typical
    182 6/8John BrickerMahoning · 2006 · Modern Shotgun
  9. #9Non-typical
    178 1/8Richard K GilesMahoning · 2000 · Modern Shotgun
  10. #10Non-typical
    177 6/8Dannie DeboltMahoning · 1962 · Modern Shotgun
#HunterScoreYearCountyWeapon
#11Ray Notares
Ellsworth
177 5/81990MahoningModern Shotgun
#12Dale Karlen
Salem
177 1/81994MahoningModern Shotgun
#13Henry Smith
Salem
175 2/81980MahoningModern Shotgun
#14Gary Kolasky
Youngstown
171 5/81983MahoningModern Shotgun
#15Richard Novicky
Vienna
170 1/8—MahoningModern Shotgun
#16Matt Heineman
Salem
167 6/81997MahoningModern Shotgun
#17Sherman Champlin
Newton Falls
166 5/82008MahoningModern Shotgun
#18Jerry Weingart
Beloit
166 1/82001MahoningModern Shotgun
#19Larry Macovitz
Youngstown
165 6/82007MahoningModern Shotgun
#20James L Putnam
Niles
160 4/81985MahoningModern Shotgun

Page views are counted with Vercel Analytics. No ads, and we don't sell your data. Privacy · Terms

Ohio non-typical whitetail records — TrophyBook