TB
TrophyBook
Ohio harvest intel
Buckeye Big Buck Club · ODNR record book

Ohio non-typical whitetail records

Every non-typical buck in the Buckeye Big Buck Club record book, ranked by net score. Non-typical racks only (minimum 160 inches).

Source: Buckeye Big Buck Club record book (ODNR), retrieved Sep 15, 2026. How the records work

WeaponAllModern ShotgunCrossbowLong BowMuzzleloaderStraight-Walled RifleHand Gun
DecadeAll2020s2010s2000s1990s1980sBefore 1980
Adams: 18 entriesAllen: 3 entriesAshland: 31 entriesAshtabula: 20 entriesAthens: 32 entriesAuglaize: 11 entriesBelmont: 20 entriesBrown: 15 entriesButler: 7 entriesCarroll: 33 entriesChampaign: 14 entriesClark: 6 entriesClermont: 14 entriesClinton: 19 entriesColumbiana: 21 entriesCoshocton: 46 entriesCrawford: 16 entriesCuyahoga: 0 entriesDarke: 8 entriesDefiance: 6 entriesDelaware: 20 entriesErie: 7 entriesFairfield: 33 entriesFayette: 7 entriesFranklin: 10 entriesFulton: 6 entriesGallia: 16 entriesGeauga: 7 entriesGreene: 13 entriesGuernsey: 29 entriesHamilton: 3 entriesHancock: 9 entriesHardin: 18 entriesHarrison: 23 entriesHenry: 5 entriesHighland: 28 entriesHocking: 18 entriesHolmes: 20 entriesHuron: 18 entriesJackson: 23 entriesJefferson: 29 entriesKnox: 31 entriesLake: 3 entriesLawrence: 8 entriesLicking: 65 entriesLogan: 15 entriesLorain: 18 entriesLucas: 4 entriesMadison: 7 entriesMahoning: 20 entriesMarion: 12 entriesMedina: 8 entriesMeigs: 17 entriesMercer: 3 entriesMiami: 3 entriesMonroe: 10 entriesMontgomery: 3 entriesMorgan: 18 entriesMorrow: 27 entriesMuskingum: 44 entriesNoble: 25 entriesOttawa: 2 entriesPaulding: 8 entriesPerry: 24 entriesPickaway: 15 entriesPike: 15 entriesPortage: 10 entriesPreble: 9 entriesPutnam: 2 entriesRichland: 23 entriesRoss: 35 entriesSandusky: 9 entriesScioto: 14 entriesSeneca: 13 entriesShelby: 6 entriesStark: 9 entriesSummit: 2 entriesTrumbull: 14 entriesTuscarawas: 40 entriesUnion: 7 entriesVan Wert: 1 entryVinton: 23 entriesWarren: 3 entriesWashington: 26 entriesWayne: 12 entriesWilliams: 9 entriesWood: 10 entriesWyandot: 18 entries

Where they were taken

Carroll County: 33 entries.

Show every countyCarroll County page

  1. Licking65
  2. Coshocton46
  3. Muskingum44
  4. Tuscarawas40
  5. Ross35
  6. Carroll33
  7. Fairfield33
  8. Athens32

Ranked by net score

33 of 3,818 entries match

  1. #1Non-typical
    207 2/8Jerry JohnsonCarroll · 2006 · Modern Shotgun
  2. #2Non-typical
    199 6/8Eddie E MayleCarroll · 2003 · Modern Shotgun
  3. #3Non-typical
    196 4/8Roger WrightCarroll · 1994 · Modern Shotgun
  4. #4Non-typical
    186 3/8Chuck CaldwellCarroll · 1980 · Modern Shotgun
  5. #5Non-typical
    185 5/8Robert A MayleCarroll · 1990 · Modern Shotgun
  6. #6Non-typical
    185 5/8Shane A ElifritzCarroll · 2007 · Modern Shotgun
  7. #7Non-typical
    183 0/8Brian SandenbeckCarroll · 2005 · Modern Shotgun
  8. #8Non-typical
    182 2/8Aaron CatlettCarroll · 1995 · Modern Shotgun
  9. #9Non-typical
    181 7/8Dale E HullCarroll · 1994 · Modern Shotgun
  10. #10Non-typical
    181 1/8James W CarterCarroll · 1981 · Modern Shotgun
#HunterScoreYearCountyWeapon
#11Michael Wharton
New Vienna
178 6/81980CarrollModern Shotgun
#12Merle Edie
Bowerstown
178 4/81980CarrollModern Shotgun
#13Brian F Barnes
Louisville
178 0/82008CarrollModern Shotgun
#14Brian L Wagner
Malvern
177 6/81990CarrollModern Shotgun
#15Bruce E Weisburn
Waynesburg
175 5/81989CarrollModern Shotgun
#16Bruce B Horton
Zoarville
175 3/81993CarrollModern Shotgun
#17Tim Vlaiku
Alliance
174 2/82013CarrollModern Shotgun
#18Jeff Marteney
Carrollton
172 4/82002CarrollModern Shotgun
#19Larry Shaw
Scio
169 7/81995CarrollModern Shotgun
#20Paul Waechter
Canton
169 6/81988CarrollModern Shotgun
#21Shane Elifritz
Carrolton
169 4/81982CarrollModern Shotgun
#22Jeff Manos
Alliance
168 4/82001CarrollModern Shotgun
#23Lonnie Brady
Minerva
168 0/81982CarrollModern Shotgun
#24Larry Wheeler
North Canton
167 5/82001CarrollModern Shotgun
#25Jason M Leyda
Euless
167 4/82000CarrollModern Shotgun
#26Daniel W Strubel
Navarre
167 1/82003CarrollModern Shotgun
#27Ron McLaughlin
New Waterford
166 3/81999CarrollModern Shotgun
#28Stan Bright
Carrollton
166 2/81981CarrollModern Shotgun
#29Curtis Randolph
Salineville
165 6/82005CarrollModern Shotgun
#30Dale Davis
Navarre
165 5/82000CarrollModern Shotgun
#31Michael J Wells
Garfield
164 0/81991CarrollModern Shotgun
#32Larry Fletcher
Barberton
163 3/81992CarrollModern Shotgun
#33Nathan Hale
Wilmington
163 2/81953CarrollModern Shotgun

Page views are counted with Vercel Analytics. No ads, and we don't sell your data. Privacy · Terms

Ohio non-typical whitetail records — TrophyBook