TB
TrophyBook
Ohio harvest intel
Buckeye Big Buck Club · ODNR record book

Ohio non-typical whitetail records

Every non-typical buck in the Buckeye Big Buck Club record book, ranked by net score. Non-typical racks only (minimum 160 inches).

Source: Buckeye Big Buck Club record book (ODNR), retrieved Sep 15, 2026. How the records work

WeaponAllModern ShotgunCrossbowLong BowMuzzleloaderStraight-Walled RifleHand Gun
DecadeAll2020s2010s2000s1990s1980sBefore 1980
Adams: 16 entriesAllen: 10 entriesAshland: 31 entriesAshtabula: 12 entriesAthens: 17 entriesAuglaize: 5 entriesBelmont: 10 entriesBrown: 13 entriesButler: 9 entriesCarroll: 23 entriesChampaign: 9 entriesClark: 6 entriesClermont: 17 entriesClinton: 20 entriesColumbiana: 13 entriesCoshocton: 34 entriesCrawford: 9 entriesCuyahoga: 3 entriesDarke: 5 entriesDefiance: 5 entriesDelaware: 34 entriesErie: 5 entriesFairfield: 28 entriesFayette: 4 entriesFranklin: 16 entriesFulton: 2 entriesGallia: 4 entriesGeauga: 7 entriesGreene: 8 entriesGuernsey: 17 entriesHamilton: 5 entriesHancock: 15 entriesHardin: 13 entriesHarrison: 21 entriesHenry: 3 entriesHighland: 17 entriesHocking: 13 entriesHolmes: 14 entriesHuron: 13 entriesJackson: 9 entriesJefferson: 21 entriesKnox: 25 entriesLake: 5 entriesLawrence: 5 entriesLicking: 58 entriesLogan: 20 entriesLorain: 20 entriesLucas: 6 entriesMadison: 10 entriesMahoning: 10 entriesMarion: 12 entriesMedina: 14 entriesMeigs: 14 entriesMercer: 1 entryMiami: 8 entriesMonroe: 2 entriesMontgomery: 6 entriesMorgan: 11 entriesMorrow: 11 entriesMuskingum: 27 entriesNoble: 14 entriesOttawa: 1 entryPaulding: 7 entriesPerry: 10 entriesPickaway: 12 entriesPike: 10 entriesPortage: 13 entriesPreble: 7 entriesPutnam: 0 entriesRichland: 15 entriesRoss: 24 entriesSandusky: 9 entriesScioto: 15 entriesSeneca: 11 entriesShelby: 6 entriesStark: 13 entriesSummit: 6 entriesTrumbull: 4 entriesTuscarawas: 31 entriesUnion: 13 entriesVan Wert: 1 entryVinton: 12 entriesWarren: 19 entriesWashington: 13 entriesWayne: 20 entriesWilliams: 8 entriesWood: 8 entriesWyandot: 14 entries

Where they were taken

Carroll County: 23 entries.

Show every countyCarroll County page

  1. Licking58
  2. Coshocton34
  3. Delaware34
  4. Ashland31
  5. Tuscarawas31
  6. Fairfield28
  7. Muskingum27
  8. Knox25

Ranked by net score

23 of 3,818 entries match

  1. #1Non-typical
    247 1/8Marlon HaleCarroll · 2005 · Crossbow
  2. #2Non-typical
    207 2/8Jerry JohnsonCarroll · 2006 · Modern Shotgun
  3. #3Non-typical
    199 6/8Eddie E MayleCarroll · 2003 · Modern Shotgun
  4. #4Non-typical
    192 2/8Dana A FiliskyCarroll · 2007 · Crossbow
  5. #5Non-typical
    186 1/8Anthony S DiMarcoCarroll · 2006 · Muzzleloader
  6. #6Non-typical
    185 5/8Shane A ElifritzCarroll · 2007 · Modern Shotgun
  7. #7Non-typical
    183 0/8Brian SandenbeckCarroll · 2005 · Modern Shotgun
  8. #8Non-typical
    178 7/8John ShockeyCarroll · 2008
  9. #9Non-typical
    178 0/8Brian F BarnesCarroll · 2008 · Modern Shotgun
  10. #10Non-typical
    172 4/8Jeff MarteneyCarroll · 2002 · Modern Shotgun
#HunterScoreYearCountyWeapon
#11Rodger Wright
Lakemore
170 6/82001CarrollMuzzleloader
#12William F Prendergast
Kensington
169 0/82000CarrollMuzzleloader
#13Jeff Manos
Alliance
168 4/82001CarrollModern Shotgun
#14Larry Wheeler
North Canton
167 5/82001CarrollModern Shotgun
#15Jason M Leyda
Euless
167 4/82000CarrollModern Shotgun
#16Daniel W Strubel
Navarre
167 1/82003CarrollModern Shotgun
#17Curtis Randolph
Salineville
165 6/82005CarrollModern Shotgun
#18Dale Davis
Navarre
165 5/82000CarrollModern Shotgun
#19Tim Smith
Pulaski
165 4/82009CarrollLong Bow
#20Clifford Roberts
Mineral
163 7/82001CarrollLong Bow
#21Arthur R Wilson
Salineville
162 0/82005CarrollCrossbow
#22Josh Keane
Bolivar
161 5/82008CarrollLong Bow
#23Paul Leach
Salem
160 3/82003CarrollMuzzleloader

Page views are counted with Vercel Analytics. No ads, and we don't sell your data. Privacy · Terms

Ohio non-typical whitetail records — TrophyBook